Official Box Score - Final
Seton Hall at Butler
3/22/2026 at Butler Softball Fld (Indianapolis, Ind.)

Score by Innings123456RHELOB
Seton Hall000030 3836
Butler006032 111018
Win: Alyx Johnson (3-0)Loss: Karissa Dupuis (3-2)Save: None.


Seton Hall 3 (10-13; 2-6BIG EAST )
#PlayerPosABRHRBIBBKPOAELOB
1 Angelina BenitezCF3110002000
5 Katey BrennanLF2010104010
35 Sophia DeMarco1B2012114000
18 Naya MartinezRF3000012000
50 Loreale Blake2B3000020304
22 Lea KosinskiDP3000000000
20 Erin HowardC3020002110
3 Elisabeth Figliolino (PR)0100000000
7 Andrea PerezSS3020002000
24 Christina Ginex3B3110001112
23 Karissa DupuisP0000000100
19 Rachael Schumann (P)0000000000
12 Kyra Kreuscher (P)0000000000
Totals253822417636
BATTING
2B: Brennan [7] (off Johnson); DeMarco [3] (off Petran); Perez [7] (off Johnson).
TB: Brennan 2; DeMarco 2; Perez 3.
Team RISP: 1-6.
Butler 11 (12-9; 5-0BIG EAST )
#PlayerPosABRHRBIBBKPOAELOB
19 Cate LehnerCF5232002000
12 Hailey CongerRF5234002012
1 Kayla Preiss2B3110102000
17 Makena Alexander1B2011205000
25 Rachel Hunt (PR)0000000000
29 Olivia RobardsSS2001100203
9 Alona Boydston (PH)DP1100200000
10 Emily Todor (PR)0000000000
13 Kieli RyanC1101104002
27 Paige Lillie (PH)1010000000
21 Kendall Graves3B3200001200
2 Erin Clark (PH)1000000000
22 Olivia RobertsLF2211102101
8 Alyx JohnsonP0000000000
15 Katie Petran (P)0000000000
Totals261110108018518
BATTING
2B: Conger [7] (off Schumann); Alexander [6] (off Schumann).
TB: Conger 4; Alexander 2. 2-Out RBI: Lehner 2; Conger 2; Alexander. SH: Ryan. SF: Robards. HBP: Roberts [3].
Team RISP: 4-16.
BASERUNNING
SB: Lehner [17] (p Schumann/c Howard) (p Kreuscher/c Howard); Graves [1] (p Schumann/c Howard) (p Kreuscher/c Howard).

SETON HAiphrerbbkbfabnpst
23 Karissa Dupuis (L)2.24625019117237
19 Rachael Schumann2.14332013114321
12 Kyra Kreuscher0.222210642816
Totals5.21011780382614374
WP: Dupuis [7]. HB: Kreuscher [3]. SFA: Dupuis.
GO-FO: Dupuis 3-5; Schumann 1-6; Kreuscher 2-0.
BUTLERiphrerbbkbfabnpst
8 Alyx Johnson (W)4.16331319186542
15 Katie Petran1.220011872716
Totals6.08332427259258
GO-FO: Johnson 3-6; Petran 1-3.

Umpires: HP: Derek Smith; 1B: Gavin Ramsey; 2B: ; 3B: Paul Melcher.
First Pitch: 12:00 PM. Duration:2:00.
Attendance: 0
Weather: warm, partly cloudy, breezy



Play By Play (Full) - Final
Seton Hall at Butler
3/22/2026 at Butler Softball Fld (Indianapolis, Ind.)


Score by Innings123456RHELOB
Seton Hall000030 3836
Butler006032 111018

Seton Hall starters:
1/cf/Angelina Benitez; 5/lf/Katey Brennan; 35/1b/Sophia DeMarco; 18/rf/Naya Martinez; 50/2b/Loreale Blake; 22/dp/Lea Kosinski; 20/c/Erin Howard; 7/ss/Andrea Perez; 24/3b/Christina Ginex; 23/p/Karissa Dupuis;

Butler starters:
19/cf/Cate Lehner; 12/rf/Hailey Conger; 1/2b/Kayla Preiss; 17/1b/Makena Alexander; 29/ss/Olivia Robards; 9/dp/Alona Boydston; 13/c/Kieli Ryan; 21/3b/Kendall Graves; 22/lf/Olivia Roberts; 8/p/Alyx Johnson;


1st Inning
Top of 1st - SETON HA batting
Angelina Benitez flied out to cf (0-2 KF).
Katey Brennan doubled to center field (2-2 KBFB).
Sophia DeMarco walked (3-1 SBBBB).
Naya Martinez struck out swinging (3-2 KBFBBFS).
Loreale Blake flied out to rf (0-0).

Bottom of 1st - BUTLER batting
Cate Lehner grounded out to 2b (1-0 B).
Hailey Conger lined out to lf (0-0).
Kayla Preiss singled, advanced to second on an error by lf (0-0).
Makena Alexander walked (3-2 BKFBBB).
Olivia Robards lined out to 3b (1-1 KB).

This InningRHEL
SETON HA0102
BUTLER0102
2nd Inning
Top of 2nd - SETON HA batting
Lea Kosinski grounded out to 3b (1-0 B).
Erin Howard singled to right field (2-2 KBKFB).
Andrea Perez flied out to cf (0-2 FK); Erin Howard advanced to second.
Christina Ginex popped up to 1b (1-0 B).

Bottom of 2nd - BUTLER batting
Alona Boydston walked (3-2 BKFBBB).
Kieli Ryan grounded out to c, SAC, bunt (0-0); Alona Boydston advanced to second.
Emily Todor pinch ran for Alona Boydston.
Kendall Graves lined out to cf (1-1 FB).
Emily Todor advanced to third on a wild pitch.
Olivia Roberts lined out to lf (3-2 BKBFB).

This InningRHEL
SETON HA0101
BUTLER0001
3rd Inning
Top of 3rd - SETON HA batting
Angelina Benitez grounded out to ss (2-2 KBFB).
Katey Brennan fouled out to lf (1-2 BFF).
Sophia DeMarco struck out swinging (3-2 BKBBKFFS).

Bottom of 3rd - BUTLER batting
Cate Lehner singled, bunt (2-1 BBF).
Hailey Conger singled, bunt (3-1 BBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second.
Kayla Preiss reached first on an error by 3b, advanced to second (1-2 SFFFBF); Hailey Conger advanced to third; Cate Lehner scored, unearned.
Makena Alexander walked (3-0 BBBB).
Olivia Robards lined out to lf, sacrifice fly, RBI (1-0 B); Makena Alexander advanced to second; Kayla Preiss advanced to third; Hailey Conger scored.
Alona Boydston pinch hit for Emily Todor.
Alona Boydston reached on catcher's interference (0-2 KF).
Kieli Ryan walked, RBI (3-0 BBBB); Alona Boydston advanced to second; Makena Alexander advanced to third; Kayla Preiss scored.
Kendall Graves reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 KSB); Kieli Ryan advanced to second; Alona Boydston advanced to third; Makena Alexander out at home p to c.
Olivia Roberts walked, RBI (3-1 BKBBB); Kendall Graves advanced to second; Kieli Ryan advanced to third; Alona Boydston scored, unearned.
Cate Lehner singled to right field, 2 RBI (1-2 FBF); Olivia Roberts advanced to third; Kendall Graves scored, unearned; Kieli Ryan scored, unearned.
Rachael Schumann to p for Karissa Dupuis.
Cate Lehner stole second.
Hailey Conger grounded out to 2b (1-1 KB).

This InningRHEL
SETON HA0000
BUTLER6322
4th Inning
Top of 4th - SETON HA batting
Naya Martinez lined out to 2b (0-0).
Loreale Blake struck out swinging (3-2 BSBFBFS).
Lea Kosinski grounded out to ss (0-0).

Bottom of 4th - BUTLER batting
Kayla Preiss walked (3-2 KBBBKB).
Makena Alexander flied out to rf (3-2 BKBBK).
Olivia Robards walked (3-0 BBBB); Kayla Preiss advanced to second.
Alona Boydston flied out to cf (0-0).
Kieli Ryan flied out to lf (2-0 BB).

This InningRHEL
SETON HA0000
BUTLER0002
5th Inning
Top of 5th - SETON HA batting
Erin Howard singled to right center (0-2 KK).
Elisabeth Figliolino pinch ran for Erin Howard.
Andrea Perez doubled, out at third lf to 3b (1-0 B); Elisabeth Figliolino advanced to third, scored on an error by rf.
Christina Ginex singled to left center (0-0).
Angelina Benitez singled through the left side (0-0); Christina Ginex advanced to second.
Katie Petran to p for Alyx Johnson.
Katey Brennan walked (3-0 BBBB); Angelina Benitez advanced to second; Christina Ginex advanced to third.
Sophia DeMarco doubled to left center, 2 RBI (0-0); Katey Brennan advanced to third; Angelina Benitez scored; Christina Ginex scored.
Naya Martinez grounded out to 3b (1-2 KFB).
Loreale Blake struck out swinging (0-2 SFS).

Bottom of 5th - BUTLER batting
Erin Howard to c for Elisabeth Figliolino.
Erin Clark pinch hit for Kendall Graves.
Erin Clark fouled out to 1b (0-0).
Olivia Roberts singled to center field (1-2 SKB).
Cate Lehner singled, bunt (0-0); Olivia Roberts advanced to second.
Hailey Conger doubled to right center, 2 RBI (0-0); Cate Lehner scored; Olivia Roberts scored.
Kayla Preiss popped up to ss (2-1 BFB).
Makena Alexander doubled to center field, RBI (3-2 BBBKK); Hailey Conger scored.
Rachel Hunt pinch ran for Makena Alexander.
Olivia Robards flied out to rf (2-0 BB).

This InningRHEL
SETON HA3502
BUTLER3401
6th Inning
Top of 6th - SETON HA batting
Makena Alexander to 1b for Rachel Hunt.
Kendall Graves to 3b for Erin Clark.
Lea Kosinski flied out to rf (2-0 BB).
Erin Howard popped up to 2b (1-1 KB).
Andrea Perez singled up the middle (2-2 FFBB).
Christina Ginex flied out to lf (1-2 BKF).

Bottom of 6th - BUTLER batting
Kyra Kreuscher to p for Rachael Schumann.
Alona Boydston walked (3-0 BBBB).
Paige Lillie pinch hit for Kieli Ryan.
Paige Lillie singled up the middle (1-1 KB); Alona Boydston advanced to second.
Kendall Graves reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 FFBFF); Paige Lillie out at second 2b to ss; Alona Boydston advanced to third.
Kendall Graves stole second.
Olivia Roberts hit by pitch (2-2 BKSH).
Cate Lehner reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 KFFB); Olivia Roberts advanced to second; Kendall Graves advanced to third; Alona Boydston out at home 3b to c.
Hailey Conger singled to left field, 2 RBI (3-2 SBBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second; Olivia Roberts scored; Kendall Graves scored.

This InningRHEL
SETON HA0101
BUTLER2202


Scoring Innings - Final
Seton Hall at Butler
3/22/2026 at Butler Softball Fld (Indianapolis, Ind.)


Score by Innings123456RHELOB
Seton Hall000030 3836
Butler006032 111018

Seton Hall starters:
1/cf/Angelina Benitez; 5/lf/Katey Brennan; 35/1b/Sophia DeMarco; 18/rf/Naya Martinez; 50/2b/Loreale Blake; 22/dp/Lea Kosinski; 20/c/Erin Howard; 7/ss/Andrea Perez; 24/3b/Christina Ginex; 23/p/Karissa Dupuis;

Butler starters:
19/cf/Cate Lehner; 12/rf/Hailey Conger; 1/2b/Kayla Preiss; 17/1b/Makena Alexander; 29/ss/Olivia Robards; 9/dp/Alona Boydston; 13/c/Kieli Ryan; 21/3b/Kendall Graves; 22/lf/Olivia Roberts; 8/p/Alyx Johnson;


Bottom of 3rd - BUTLER batting
Cate Lehner singled, bunt (2-1 BBF).
Hailey Conger singled, bunt (3-1 BBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second.
Kayla Preiss reached first on an error by 3b, advanced to second (1-2 SFFFBF); Hailey Conger advanced to third; Cate Lehner scored, unearned.
Makena Alexander walked (3-0 BBBB).
Olivia Robards lined out to lf, sacrifice fly, RBI (1-0 B); Makena Alexander advanced to second; Kayla Preiss advanced to third; Hailey Conger scored.
Alona Boydston pinch hit for Emily Todor.
Alona Boydston reached on catcher's interference (0-2 KF).
Kieli Ryan walked, RBI (3-0 BBBB); Alona Boydston advanced to second; Makena Alexander advanced to third; Kayla Preiss scored.
Kendall Graves reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 KSB); Kieli Ryan advanced to second; Alona Boydston advanced to third; Makena Alexander out at home p to c.
Olivia Roberts walked, RBI (3-1 BKBBB); Kendall Graves advanced to second; Kieli Ryan advanced to third; Alona Boydston scored, unearned.
Cate Lehner singled to right field, 2 RBI (1-2 FBF); Olivia Roberts advanced to third; Kendall Graves scored, unearned; Kieli Ryan scored, unearned.
Rachael Schumann to p for Karissa Dupuis.
Cate Lehner stole second.
Hailey Conger grounded out to 2b (1-1 KB).
6 R, 3 H, 2 E, 2 LOB.

Top of 5th - SETON HA batting
Erin Howard singled to right center (0-2 KK).
Elisabeth Figliolino pinch ran for Erin Howard.
Andrea Perez doubled, out at third lf to 3b (1-0 B); Elisabeth Figliolino advanced to third, scored on an error by rf.
Christina Ginex singled to left center (0-0).
Angelina Benitez singled through the left side (0-0); Christina Ginex advanced to second.
Katie Petran to p for Alyx Johnson.
Katey Brennan walked (3-0 BBBB); Angelina Benitez advanced to second; Christina Ginex advanced to third.
Sophia DeMarco doubled to left center, 2 RBI (0-0); Katey Brennan advanced to third; Angelina Benitez scored; Christina Ginex scored.
Naya Martinez grounded out to 3b (1-2 KFB).
Loreale Blake struck out swinging (0-2 SFS).
3 R, 5 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.

Bottom of 5th - BUTLER batting
Erin Howard to c for Elisabeth Figliolino.
Erin Clark pinch hit for Kendall Graves.
Erin Clark fouled out to 1b (0-0).
Olivia Roberts singled to center field (1-2 SKB).
Cate Lehner singled, bunt (0-0); Olivia Roberts advanced to second.
Hailey Conger doubled to right center, 2 RBI (0-0); Cate Lehner scored; Olivia Roberts scored.
Kayla Preiss popped up to ss (2-1 BFB).
Makena Alexander doubled to center field, RBI (3-2 BBBKK); Hailey Conger scored.
Rachel Hunt pinch ran for Makena Alexander.
Olivia Robards flied out to rf (2-0 BB).
3 R, 4 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.

Bottom of 6th - BUTLER batting
Kyra Kreuscher to p for Rachael Schumann.
Alona Boydston walked (3-0 BBBB).
Paige Lillie pinch hit for Kieli Ryan.
Paige Lillie singled up the middle (1-1 KB); Alona Boydston advanced to second.
Kendall Graves reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 FFBFF); Paige Lillie out at second 2b to ss; Alona Boydston advanced to third.
Kendall Graves stole second.
Olivia Roberts hit by pitch (2-2 BKSH).
Cate Lehner reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 KFFB); Olivia Roberts advanced to second; Kendall Graves advanced to third; Alona Boydston out at home 3b to c.
Hailey Conger singled to left field, 2 RBI (3-2 SBBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second; Olivia Roberts scored; Kendall Graves scored.
2 R, 2 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.



Seton Hall at Butler
3/22/2026 at Butler Softball Fld (Indianapolis, Ind.)
Score by Innings123456RHELOB
Seton Hall000030 3836
Butler006032 111018
Seton Hall Scorecard
#PlayerPos123456ABRHRBI
1
#1 Angelina Benitez
cf
*
F8
*
G6
1B
LS
3
1
1
0
2
#5 Katey Brennan
lf
2B
8
*
FF7
BB
2
0
1
0
3
#35 Sophia DeMarco
1b
BB
*
K
2B
7
2RBI
2
0
1
2
4
#18 Naya Martinez
rf
*
K
*
L4
*
G5
3
0
0
0
5
#50 Loreale Blake
2b
*
F9
*
K
*
K
3
0
0
0
6
#22 Lea Kosinski
dp
*
G5
*
G6
*
F9
3
0
0
0
7
#20 Erin Howard
#3 Elisabeth Figliolino
c
1B
9
1B
9
*
P4
3
0
0
1
2
0
0
0
8
#7 Andrea Perez
ss
*
F8
2B
5
1B
MI
3
0
2
0
9
#24 Christina Ginex
3b
*
P3
1B
7
*
F7
3
1
1
0
Totals25382
Runs0000303
Hits1100518
Errors0000001
LOB2100216
SETON HAiphrerbbkbfabnpst
23 Karissa Dupuis (L)2.24625019117237
19 Rachael Schumann2.14332013114321
12 Kyra Kreuscher0.222210642816
Totals5.21011780382614374
WP: Dupuis [7]. HB: Kreuscher [3]. SFA: Dupuis.
GO-FO: Dupuis 3-5; Schumann 1-6; Kreuscher 2-0.


Seton Hall at Butler
3/22/2026 at Butler Softball Fld (Indianapolis, Ind.)
Score by Innings123456RHELOB
Seton Hall000030 3836
Butler006032 111018
Butler Scorecard
#PlayerPos123456ABRHRBI
1
#19 Cate Lehner
cf
*
G4
1B
SB2
1B
9
2RBI
SB2
1B
FC5-2
5
2
3
2
2
#12 Hailey Conger
rf
*
L7
1B
E
*
G4
2B
9
2RBI
1B
7
2RBI
5
2
3
4
3
#1 Kayla Preiss
2b
1B
7
E5
BB
*
P6
3
1
1
0
4
#17 Makena Alexander
#25 Rachel Hunt
1b
BB
*
BB
OUT
*
F9
2B
8
1RBI
2
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
5
#29 Olivia Robards
ss
*
L5
*
L7
1RBI
BB
*
F9
2
0
0
1
6
#9 Alona Boydston
#10 Emily Todor
dp
BB
Boydston reached on catcher's interference
*
F8
*
BB
OUT
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
7
#13 Kieli Ryan
#27 Paige Lillie
ph
*
G2
SH
BB
1RBI
*
F7
*
1B
MI
OUT
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
0
8
#21 Kendall Graves
#2 Erin Clark
3b
*
L8
FC1-2
*
FF3
FC4-6
SB2
3
1
2
0
0
0
0
0
9
#22 Olivia Roberts
lf
*
L7
BB
1RBI
1B
8
HBP
2
2
1
1
Totals26111010
Runs00603211
Hits10304210
Errors0020003
LOB2122128
BUTLERiphrerbbkbfabnpst
8 Alyx Johnson (W)4.16331319186542
15 Katie Petran1.220011872716
Totals6.08332427259258
GO-FO: Johnson 3-6; Petran 1-3.